Are You There, Karma? It’s Me, Jane by Christine Zolendz

Sensible women do not believe in love at first sight. And Jane Nash is one sensible woman (well, most of the time). But when her eyes–and lips–land on a complete stranger at a baseball game, Jane feels like she’s hit a grand slam as the crowd roars its approval. However, in the chaos of the stadium, she loses Mr. Perfect in a throng of fans and foam fingers.
Determined to find him again, Jane sets off on a mission for that baseball fan of her dreams. Suddenly, she gets a crash course in Karma, learning quickly that Karma’s one tricky wench. But Karma has plans of her own–and Jane is about to get everything she’s ever wanted–and nothing she ever expected.