Three Wishes by Mary J. Williams

Everyone deserves a second chance, right? WRONG!

The only man Andi Benedict ever loved—the man who broke her heart—is back in town. Forgive and forget? Not on your life!
Andi is the oldest Benedict sister. Responsible, sensible, she watched her mother run through men with as much care and thought as she would give a tissue from a box. Her father wasn’t any better. In Andi’s world, marriage wasn’t forever—just a pit-stop until someone better came along.
Yet, for reasons she can’t explain, Andi believes in love. She knows when she falls it will be forever. When she meets Noah Brennan, the chemistry between them is instantaneous. But give her heart to him? Never. He’s completely wrong for her.

Noah Brennan burns with ambition. He wants more than the nothing he has and is determined to claw his way to the top. Women are necessary fun, but he doesn’t have time for a relationship. As for Andi Benedict? She’s too sophisticated for a man like him. Too cool and collected. Too rich. She’s high society, he’s the wrong side of the tracks. She’s completely wrong for him. And the one woman he can’t do without.
You can’t plan for love. Inconvenient and impossible, Andi and Noah know the truth—they belong together.

Unfortunately, not everyone agrees. Torn apart by the people they thought they could trust, the years pass. Andi believes she’s over the man who broke her heart. One look is all it takes to tell her she isn’t over her first love. But old wounds run deep.
Can Andi ever trust Noah again? Or, will the lies and secrets that broke them apart be too much for them to overcome?