Over You by Virginia May

The senior baseball star and the freshman ugly duckling. It was never going to work out.
But ugly ducklings grow up. They become strong and beautiful swans. When Ilsa discovers that jock Lloyd is still breaking hearts years after they left school, she’s determined to teach him a lesson. She’ll be the first woman to turn him down, because there’s no way his good looks, honed body and seductive conversation will turn her head.
Lloyd loves women. He loves making them feel good about themselves. There’s no way he’d ever restrict himself to just one.
Until he meets Ilsa. It’s all fun – hot, sexy fun – until the time comes to walk away. Leaving her shouldn’t be difficult, but somehow, he can’t seem to get over her.